Saturday, October 27, 2012

AR - Rehabilitation for sex offenders has varying success rates

Original Article


By Allison Munn

JONESBORO (KAIT) - In the wake of [name withheld] abducting a 5-year-old Poplar Bluff girl, in addition to his extensive sex offender background, Region 8 News looked into whether or not a sex offender can be rehabilitated.
- This is what ticks us off. They are talking about sex offenders in general, from the statements above, but below they, as usual, lump all ex-sex offenders into the child molesting, pedophile predator group, which is far from the truth. True pedophiles are rare, not the norm like they make it out to be. If you want to talk about child molesters and true pedophiles, then do so, stop putting all offenders into one basket.

Licensed Psychologist, Dr. Phil Hestand told Region 8 News results vary.

"Probably about half of the people who receive adequate treatment do not re-offend," Hestand said. He explained that pedophilia isn't comparable to addiction.
- By him saying "probably," shows he's making a guess. The facts, from the many studies we've read, is that a majority, around 90% or more, do not re-offend, and that accounts for all types of ex-offenders. He then goes on to talk about pedophilia as if all ex-sex offenders are pedophiles, which is not true. True pedophiles account for 5% or less of all ex-sex offenders.

"For whatever reason, they're focused on children for sexual gratification," Hestand said. "In some ways it's a sexual orientation."
- Pedophiles, yes, but not all sex offenders are pedophiles.

But, he told Region 8 News, many treatment programs offered for pedophiles are similar to that of a drug or alcohol treatment program. Programs like relapse prevention and cognitive behavioral therapy have proven to be somewhat effective.

"Because frankly, most people believe that you can't take that sexual attraction away," Dr. Hestand said.

However, Dr. Hestand said even adequate relapse prevention programs have only shown to be effective about half of the time.

These programs are in comparison to punishment related programs, which Dr. Hestand said are less effective.

"Things like that have been tried. You know, punishment, shaming, shock therapies," he explained. "It just hasn't worked. They've tried castration."

Dr. Hestand said they have to be realistic about what kind of treatment will keep pedophiles from relapsing. But, since there's no set rehabilitative program for pedophiles, knowing if someone will re-offend after participating in a program is difficult to predict.

"What's available for treatment is just very variable in different parts of the country. Sometimes people may get fairly adequate treatment and sometimes people may get very little."

Dr. Hestand also mentioned that there are some medications out now that will lower testosterone levels to a very low level... and have shown some effectiveness as long as the pedophile takes the medication.
- Isn't that called chemical castration?

1 comment :

DeAnn said...

Great comments, Joe, on this article!