Amen! If an online hit-list which puts ex-sex offenders and their families in danger is okay, then we should have an online registry for all sinners. What's good for one group is good for all groups. Fair is fair, right? Don't get me wrong. I don't agree in ANY registry, but if it's good enough to eradicate one groups rights, then everyone should be treated the same, we are all suppose to be treated as equals, right? I'd love to know where gun owners live, especially twisted individuals like Valerie Parkhurst in Florida.
Former New York City mayoral candidate and author Mark Green advocated for new legislation that would allow people to identify and locate gun owners who lived in their neighborhoods. He compared it to the already existing "Megan's Law," which lets citizens know if a convicted sex offender lives near them.
Then he flat-out compared sex offenders to gun owners.
"If we have a Megan's Law — because I think almost everyone might agree — that if you're a convicted child molester, a neighbor might want to know that because they're in your home, safe, but maybe they could hurt someone else," Green said, adding "Same thing with guns."
"There may be people who think the more concealed weapons, the better. Fine. Live in Texas or Florida," he said.
Green was reacting to the Journal News' decision to publish the names and addresses of pistol permit holders in two New York counties. The obvious flaw in Green's argument is that legal gun owners are not criminals and therefore no reasonable rationale exists to place gun owners on some sort of database similar to that of a sex offender registry.
- Many are not, that is true, but many have committed crimes and just haven't been caught yet. Once a person has done their time, they should not continually be harassed, made to live under bridges, jobless, etc, they should be able to move on with their lives, just like anybody else. What about all the other criminals? I think we should post everybody's photo, name, address and work location online for all to see, so we know everybody who lives around us. We have a right to know that, right?
Even Michael Smerconish, Chris Matthews' fill-in host, disagreed with Green's assessment and said he was not comparing lawful gun owners with convicted child molesters in any way.
However, Smerconish did agree that gun owner information should be publicly available. Putnam County, N.Y., Executive Maryellen Odell disagreed and said releasing lawful gun owners' information was an invasion of privacy.